PRINCIPLE OF POWER DIVISION NOT PRESERVED
Support A1+!May 11 the National Assembly in the first reading adopted as a basis the draft of constitutional amendments submitted by the coalition. The draft that does not solve the main problem of reformation- the regulation of balance of power between the states bodies. The Venice Commission adheres to the same opinion.
“Even in December 2004 the conclusion said that the draft does not secure the principle of power balance, moreover the President still preserves his dominating position in the political system”, constitutional right specialist Vardan Poghosyan reminds. In his words, both in the acting Constitution and the adopted draft the government still bears a double responsibility before the National Assembly and the President. “It means that the President can any moment dismiss the Prime Minister, what means that the government activity directly depends on the President’s will.
Vardan Poghosyan assures that in none of the countries with semi-presidential government system the government bears double responsibility. “Semi-presidential system supposes that the government that enlists the support of the parliament is functioning until it loses the NA’s trust. Besides the problem of dismissing the Premier the draft adopted leaves the government formation in the President’s hands. The only change is that the NA will be dissolved not after the third but after the second time it does not approve the government's program” Vardan Poghosyan said.
In his words, these two clauses are enough to be convinced that the draft violates the logics of the semi-presidential government system. Thus we are dealing not with the semi-presidential but the super-presidential system. “The government is obliged to take decisions on the basis on normative acts by the President. Though the President does not ratify decision of the government he has the right to suspend any decision and appeal to the constitutional court to check it with the Constitution. At that the matter concerns not only the normative but also individual decisions by the government”, V. Poghosyan noted.
According to the draft adopted though the President does not preside over the government sittings he can exercise his right to do that.
The functions of the President remain almost unchanged . “There is a gap in Article 49. It says that for performing his functions the President is empowered to undertake any steps; thus the President has boundless authority. Consequently, Article 49 should define that the President of the republic can perform his functions within his authority only”, V. Poghosyan stressed. According to him, the draft does not solve the problem of expanding the authority of the National Assembly. On one hand its authority on exercising control is insignificant, on the other hand with the absence of precise majority it can turn into an uncontrollable body that can cause governmental crisis.
In its conclusion the Venice Commission with regret noted the reduction of the number of questions included in the legislative authority of the National Assembly (in 2001 draft -37, now – 18). The draft adopted in the first reading provides for 10 exclusive legislative authorities of the National Assembly.
Victoria Abrahamyan