Open news feed Close news feed
A A

JUDGE IS DEPENDENT AND DEFENSELESS

Politics

“The sore spot of the juridical system is the problem of independence not only of the executive bodies but also of all the power branches. Presently the Ombudsman is trying to influence the juridical independence”, judge of the Court of First Instance of Erebuni and Nubarasehn communities Ara Kubanyan considers.

The judge proposes to create mechanisms, which would exclude any interference. For this purpose the Union of Judges included Ara Kubanyan in the group working out constitutional changes. The group submitted to the NA the following suggestions: “The Articles 94 and 95 should be re-edited to transform the Justice Council into a constitutional body, which takes corresponding decision.”

Kubaryan considers that to date a judge is defenseless and one of the constitutional changes touches upon this problem: “The process of dismissing judges, arrest or calling him administrative account should be more complicated. In part, the corresponding decisions by the Justice Council should be passed only on the basis of a resolution handed down by a special commission of the Court of Cassations composed of three members” To make the independence of a judge complete the possibility to appeal the decision in the CC should be fixed in the Constitution, Ara Kubaryan considers.

According to Kubaryan the three-step juridical system justifies itself. Besides the Economic Court, he highlights the formation of the Administrative court as it will ease the work of the Courts of First Instance. The problems of administrative responsibility referring to the state bodies and officials should be settled in administrative order. Kubaryan also considers that there are cases that demand consideration in the Court of First Instance by the collective composition.

Victoria Abrahamyan