IN THE NAME OF REPUBLIC OF ARMENIA
Support A1+!Deputy representing the ARFD in the Armenian National Assembly Vostanik Marukhyan considers that the clauses on court formation have undergone long discussions and do not conflict with the international norms.
The coalition’s draft notes that the Constitutional Court, the Courts of Common Law and First Instance, the Court of Appeal, the Court of Cassations as well as other specialized courts provided by the law are functioning in Armenia. The creation of extraordinary courts like military tribunal is forbidden. The Administrative Court in Marukhyan’s opinion can be referred to the category of “other courts” and its formation can be determined by the law.
The independence of the courts is guaranteed by the Constitution and laws, the authority of the court, the order of their formation and activities are determined by the Constitution and laws as well. The coalition’s draft as a matter of fact does not include the item on a judge’s withdrawal. It is possible only in case the judge is charged of a crime. “The norms of the withdrawal can be fixed in the law but not in the Constitution”, Vostanik Marukhyan says.
In Arshak Sadoyans’ opinion not only the order of the court formation but also the formation of the Council of Justice is very important. “The composition of the Council and the independence of this body are very important. In our draft the Council is independent while the coalition makes it dependent. Nevertheless Arshak Sadoyan considers that the Council should be appointed by Council of Judges. “The council elects 9 judges and the NA -3. As for the present three-step juridical system, in his opinion it should be preserved and in future other courts can be formed”, he says.
According to the ULP as the President is the head of the state he should be empowered to appoint and dismiss the judges. The ULP draft also bans the formation of extraordinary courts.
Diana Markosyan