Open news feed Close news feed
A A

WAY TO JUST COURT FORMATION VIA INDEPENDENT JUSTICE COUNCIL

Politics

“In past the problems with the human rights were connected with the imperfection of the juridical system, absence of independence and proper guarantees”, Hrayr Tovmasyan, co-author of the constitutional amendments draft presented by Democracy public organization says.

In his words the juridical system fixed in the acting Constitution is fully dependent on the executive power and the President. “The executive power has nothing to do with the formation of the juridical corps while the Justice Council is called to secure the independence of the juridical power. However in Armenia this notion is distorted as the President is the Chairman of the Justice Council and his deputies are the Prosecutor General and the Minister of Justice. Taking into consideration the fact that the Justice Minister can bring a suit against a judge any judge will become dependent perforce.

In Tovmasyan’s opinion in such a situation the Justice Council cannot be independent. The constitutional draft presented by Democracy leaves no place for the President, Justice Minister or the Prosecutor General in the Justice Council. According to the draft, 2 judges of the Council should be elected the general council via secret vote while the National Assembly elects 2 legal experts and 2 lawyers. After resigning their salary become equal to the salary of the chairman of the Court of Cassations, enjoy immunity and are empowered to solve issues connected with the juridical corps. “There is one more important item. The judge has the right to appeal a decision against him in the Constitutional Court”, Hrayr Tovmasyan added.

The Democracy draft calls for two specialized courts – the Administrative and Economic. The latter has already been formed. “The election dispute should be left to a chamber, which should be formed under the Court of Cassations. The CC should deal with the disputes emerging between the power branches, local self-government bodies as well as individual claims. If a citizen considers that the suit brought against him conflicts with the Constitution he should have the right to appeal to the CC”, he resumed.

Victoria Abrahamyan